Saturday, March 21, 2009

UK vs HK (academic standards)

25% of all GCSE A-levels are awarded an A grade.

GCSE stands for General Certificate of Secondary Education. GCSE A-level examinations are taken by 19 years old in the UK, as the de facto entrance examination for universities. The equivalent examination in Hong Kong is the HK A-Level, or Hong Kong Advanced Level Examination.

Less than 4% of HK A-Levels are awarded an A grade.

Are the UK students 6 times better than their HK counterparts? Of course not. An UK study has shown that a C in the HKAL is on a par with an A in the GCSE A-Level.

In the UK, grade inflation is making it difficult for elite universities to choose their students. Cambridge has been said to turn away 5,000 students with straight A’s each year.

In HK, the As are so hard to get that the really good students (with multiple As) are self evident. The problems come at the lower ranges.

And when Hong Kong students try to apply to overseas universities, that’s when they are really disadvantaged. Most admissions officers at overseas universities are unaware of the great discrepancies among the standards of different education systems.


Anonymous said...

Our school report for senior forms students uses a grading system that benchmarks against the HK Cert Exam and HK Ad level. For students applying for overseas studies, we issue them their transcripts with grades applying a grade conversion table that benchmark our internal grades (at HKCE / HKAL) against GCE or O Level resulting in upgrading the internal grades by 1 / 2 grades depending on the subjects.
This way, our students would be less disadvantaged in applying for overseas studies. Ann

StephenC said...

I am happy for your students.

Unfortunately, some schools in Hong Kong do not seem to be as helpful.

Anonymous said...

Hey I am ѕo happу Ӏ found your web site, I really found you by eгroг, while I wаs seаrсhing on
Yаhoo for something else, Anyhоw І аm here
nοw anԁ would just lіke to
saу cheers fоr a іnсredible poѕt аnd a all гound thrіlling blog (I
аlso loνe the theme/dеsign), I
dоn't have time to look over it all at the minute but I have saved it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the fantastic job.

My weblog ::